What I didn’t like: Good lord, was the science in this one bad. Dear Kurtzman and Orci: The next time you play with black holes, won’t you please talk to an actual scientist? Also: “Red Matter� Seriously? Mind you, I don’t expect much out of Star Trek, science-wise, because, well. Let’s just say the track record’s just not there. Even so, at a certain point the science in one’s science fiction should at least wave in the general direction of plausibility. It’s not too much to ask for.
– Quick Review: Star Trek « Whatever
This movie is beyond good. Anyone who says anything bad about this movie has a serious chip on there shoulder from years of being called Ugly. At least now we know that you ugly on the inside too!
So good it’s bad? So bad it’s terrible?