What I didnâ€™t like: Good lord, was the science in this one bad. Dear Kurtzman and Orci: The next time you play with black holes, wonâ€™t you please talk to an actual scientist? Also: â€œRed Matterâ€? Seriously? Mind you, I donâ€™t expect much out of Star Trek, science-wise, because, well. Letâ€™s just say the track recordâ€™s just not there. Even so, at a certain point the science in oneâ€™s science fiction should at least wave in the general direction of plausibility. Itâ€™s not too much to ask for.
— Quick Review: Star Trek Â« Whatever